Customers ask for "black" or "something that won't rust" and leave the finish to you. The finish you pick changes the prep work, how you design the part, the lead time and the price. Here is how the three common finishes for steel fabrications compare, and how to choose. When a job has drawings or a spec, the spec wins.
Quick comparison
| Paint | Powder coat | Hot-dip galvanizing | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How it protects | Barrier film | Barrier film, cured in an oven | Zinc metallurgically bonded to the steel, protects as a barrier and sacrificially |
| Prep | Clean, remove mill scale and rust; blasting gives the best result | Blasting and pretreatment, needs clean steel | Done by the galvanizer in cleaning and pickling tanks |
| Part size limit | Almost none | Oven and booth size | Kettle size |
| Colors | Any | Wide range, good gloss control | Gray zinc only, unless painted or powder coated over |
| Field repair | Easy | Touch-up paint only | Zinc-rich paint or other repair methods per ASTM A780 |
| Usually done | In house or in the field | Subcontracted to a coater | Subcontracted to a galvanizer |
Paint
Paint is the most flexible finish. You can do it in house, on any size part, in the field, and in any color. Its weak spot is that it is only a film. If it is scratched to bare steel, rust can start and creep under the coating. How long it lasts depends almost entirely on surface prep and the coating system. Paint over loose mill scale or rust will fail early; abrasive blasting and a good primer and topcoat system last much longer.
Paint makes sense for large or heavy weldments that will not fit in an oven or kettle, for structural steel that will be enclosed in a building, for field welding and touch-up, and for repair work on existing structures.
Powder coat
Powder is sprayed on dry, held by static charge, then baked so it flows and cures into a hard, even film. It gives a clean, uniform look with good impact and chip resistance, and it is a favorite for railings, furniture, brackets and anything a customer will look at up close.
Things to plan for:
- Prep is everything. Coaters usually blast and pretreat. Grind weld spatter, remove slag and avoid silicone anti-spatter sprays and markers that leave residue.
- Size. The part has to fit the coater's oven and booth. Ask before you design a 30 ft rail as one piece.
- Heat. Parts go through a curing oven, so do not powder coat assemblies with rubber, plastic or other parts that cannot take the heat.
- Touch-up. Field damage can only be touched up with paint, and it will show.
Hot-dip galvanizing
In hot-dip galvanizing the whole part is cleaned, pickled, fluxed and dipped in molten zinc. The zinc bonds to the steel and coats inside and out, including the inside of tubes when they are vented properly. Damaged areas are still protected nearby because zinc corrodes before the steel does. For fabricated steel the common spec is ASTM A123; small hardware and fasteners fall under ASTM A153.
Designing for galvanizing matters more than for the other finishes:
- Vent and drain holes. Tubes, pipe and closed sections must have holes so the cleaning solutions and zinc can flow in and out, and so trapped air and moisture can escape. A closed hollow section can be dangerous in the kettle. Ask your galvanizer for their hole sizes and locations, and see ASTM A385 and the American Galvanizers Association design guidance.
- Overlapping surfaces. Lapped plates can trap pickling solution that weeps out later. Seal weld or follow your galvanizer's guidance.
- Distortion. Thin, large, or unevenly welded parts can warp from the heat. Balance welds and talk to the galvanizer about thin sheet panels.
- Kettle size. Long parts may need to be dipped in two passes or split into sections that bolt together.
- Welding galvanized steel. Welding through zinc produces zinc oxide fumes. Remove the coating at the weld area, use proper ventilation and follow the product SDS and OSHA requirements, then repair the coating.
Duplex systems: galvanize plus paint or powder
When the customer wants color and the protection of zinc, you can paint or powder coat over galvanizing. This is called a duplex system and is common for railings, bollards, site furnishings and gates. It needs special prep, because new galvanizing does not hold paint or powder well as-is. ASTM D6386 covers prep of galvanized steel for paint, and ASTM D7803 covers prep for powder coating. Powder over galvanizing can also outgas, which leaves pinholes, so many coaters preheat the parts. Tell both your galvanizer and your powder coater that the part is going duplex.
How to choose
- Indoor, dry, decorative: powder coat or paint.
- Outdoor, needs to look good: powder coat for appearance, or a duplex system for long life.
- Outdoor, utility or heavy abuse (dumpster gates, bollards, trailer parts, farm equipment): galvanizing, or duplex if color matters.
- Too big for the oven or kettle, or needs field work: paint.
Pricing the finish into your quote
Coaters and galvanizers price their own way, often by the pound, by the part or by the job, with minimum charges. Get a current quote from them and add trucking both ways and the extra lead time. Knowing the weight helps here, so run your parts through the steel weight calculator. Add your prep labor, for example grinding welds and drilling vent holes. Then put it all in the quote builder so the finish shows up in your material cost instead of coming out of your profit. For a worked gate example, see how to quote dumpster enclosure gates.
Frequently asked questions
Can you powder coat over hot-dip galvanizing?
Yes. This is called a duplex system. The galvanized surface needs special prep, covered in ASTM D7803, and many coaters preheat the parts to reduce outgassing pinholes. Tell both the galvanizer and the coater up front.
Why do galvanized tube frames need holes?
Vent and drain holes let cleaning solutions and molten zinc flow in and out, coat the inside of the tube, and let trapped air and moisture escape. Sealed hollow sections are unsafe to dip. Ask your galvanizer for hole sizes and locations.